How to overcome the societal problem of Cognitive Dissonance

COGNITIVE DISSONANCEHow to Overcome the Societal Problem of Cognitive Dissonance

VIDEO SUMMARYPlant, Prime & Praise

“If we’ve been bamboozled long enough, we tend to reject any evidence of the bamboozle.”
– Carl Sagan, The Demon-Haunted World

The Problem

Cognitive dissonance is the discomfort we feel when we learn that something we believed, and maybe defended for years, isn’t true. Admitting it feels like admitting we were fooled, so the brain often refuses the new truth. When health and politics are involved, that refusal can be deadly.

Attacking people only cements them further, and simply giving them better facts rarely changes behavior. “Winning” arguments with psychological tricks doesn’t help either. It rewards the best debater, not the person who is right. As Nassim Nicholas Taleb put it, “If you see fraud and don’t say fraud, you are a fraud.” The question is how to speak up in a way that actually helps.

The answer is not to paint people into a corner of wet cement, but to paint everyone, including ourselves, into a doorway with the truth on the other side.

1. Plant: Truth Over Identity

Start by admitting that everyone suffers from cognitive dissonance. Then plant the idea that seeking truth is the best way to live. There are two kinds of reasoning:

  • Accuracy-motivated reasoning seeks the truth. Think of the engineer who says “Let’s break stuff!”, or Julia Galef’s scout, who reports 50,000 enemy troops even after counting 5,000 the day before. Failure is just data.
  • Identity-motivated reasoning seeks proof that we’re right. Think of the politician defending a failed pet project, or the soldier defending a position no matter what. The more a belief is tied to who we are, the stronger the dissonance.

Scouts have blind spots too. They assume everyone values truth the way they do, and that evidence alone will persuade. Deep down, we resist admitting we were wrong because our ancient brain links rejection by the tribe with death, even though we respect others more when they admit mistakes.

2. Prime: Paint Everyone Into a Doorway

Before any discussion or debate, everyone answers these questions out loud, and you answer first, candidly sharing your own embarrassing mistakes:

  1. Can you share a time you were confidently wrong, and how you discovered the truth?
  2. If a belief of yours turned out to be untrue, why would it matter to know, even if uncomfortable?
  3. What do you think of the saying, “It’s easier to fool people than to convince them they have been fooled”?
  4. What are the most effective ways to help someone, or yourself, become more open to new information?
  5. What’s your reaction to the idea that an honest person must change their mind when they discover they’re mistaken?
  6. Would you consider a compelling argument objectively if it came from someone you strongly dislike?
  7. Why do some people stick with comforting beliefs even when evidence suggests they’re wrong?
  8. How would you feel about publicly admitting you were wrong about something important?
  9. Why might some people think it’s better to hold onto a comforting belief that may not be true?
  10. Do you strive to put truth above all else, even when it challenges your deepest beliefs?

If you reach a standstill, think like an engineer: “Let’s try your way and see what the data shows.” If someone insists they’ve never been wrong, end the discussion calmly instead of mocking them, and leave the door open for next time.

3. Praise: #TruthAboveEmbarrassment

When someone admits they were wrong or changes their view based on new information, stop and praise them publicly. Let the audience applaud, or shake their hand one-on-one. Nobody can watch people being celebrated for changing their minds without wanting to be one of them.

Send in stories and videos of people being praised for changing their minds, using #TruthAboveEmbarrassment, #TruthOverAll or #TruthAboveEgo. Research suggests a movement needs only about 3.5% to 5% of a population to reach a tipping point.

Smart vs. Wise

Being smart, memorizing facts and “destroying” opponents, pushes people away. Being wise means being humble, open, and vulnerable, telling stories about your own mistakes, and taking people on a journey. “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world.” – Margaret Mead